BRODLIN / CLAUDE JOINT REVIEW / PASS124
STATUS: PREPARED ONLY. NO ACTIVE TWO-TOOL SITE. Do not report a visual PASS until
the permitted runtime is active and its HTTP manifest matches this build.
Production and accepted preview are protected; never test there.

Claude uses Chrome on Denis's computer. Planned portal http://127.0.0.1:8891/
PDF Editor: http://127.0.0.1:8891/?page=pdf-editor
Create: http://127.0.0.1:8891/create-start.html?case=main
List: http://127.0.0.1:8891/create-start.html?case=list
Codex has separate localhost:8891 origin and separate codex fixtures. Do not use
Codex URLs or shared active8890 documents. Use only fixtures/claude files.
The reserved8891 runtime remains inactive following the prior rejectedlaunch;
no change of port/executor/existingruntime mapping to bypass that refusal.

Exact files/candidate origins/hashes: manifest.json and serve-files.json outside
build. Both tools have real local HTML/JS owners; no mock backend. Actual local
Fill upload interception exists; choose fixtures/claude/source.pdf then Open PDF.
Create starter calls actual snapshot API only for its exact new synthetic ID;
an existing document is reopened without reseeding/overwriting it. Starter native
behavior requires verification. Guest-local only; auth/cloud/DB actions disabled.

TEST DATA
source.pdf exactly5pages,2and5blank; source1 regular/bold/italic/coloredADI,3items,
image/signature;3Hebrew/Latin/numbers/shekel cases;4image/internal link to3/two
external linkrectangles,25/90degree text. JSON exact expectedresults alongside.
create-state.json5pages/8blocks including explicitblank/emptyblock,images,V3,
formatting/links/RTL. Independent list-state.json3plaintext items.
Source PDF Hebrew is an explicit visual-run fixture, not a logical-copy oracle;
use expected.json logical strings for selectable PDF copy/search. Do not accept
visual-only output as selectable. Preserve input and every returned output.

FIRST LIST GATE
Three texts Alpha item/Beta item/Gamma item. Selecttext.13->48->13 three cycles.
Record before/after each: UL/OL/LI structure, text, range start/end+direction,
inline/computed font and lineheight, marker styles, toolbar actualvalue, screenshot.
Expected3originalnonemptyLI; no extra empty markers; coherent text/marker size,
return restores13px typography. Save/reload/reopen/edit/save/export/openPDF.
Test partial/whole/forward/backward selections, nestedmarks, liststyles, fontfamily,
bold/colors/spacing as separate gates. Do not count nonexistent undo/redo as PASS.
PDF143 native baseline119 replicated3->5->7->9 and later15LI/reopen persists.
Prepared candidate only fullselected text-onlyLI. Atomic/partial/whitespace fallback
remains defective/open. No native candidate or finalPDF acceptance yet.

KNOWN OPEN LIMITS
PDF26 R26 damaged projection rawarchive candidate only; no actionable recovery.
R28 Foundation history unavailable on normal desktop path. R34 New confirmation/
resetrace; PDF140candidate excluded. SixNV R15,R22,R23,R29,R30,R31 retained.
PDF142 parser +UI validation pair included, individually isolated/reviewed only.
Shared new assembly allformat Fill/Create regressions not inferred from old runs.
SelectableHebrew/₪ order/selection/copy/find/fullRTL and mandatoryformats open.
Physicaldevices/background/keyboard/crash and backendfailure/retention/auth tests
not covered. PDF.js dependency/security record retained; no vendor changed.
639raw aliases in function-registry are not a complete unique feature list.
70releasecriteria:12FAIL58NV,0of14sectionsclosed before newlist evidence.

COMMAND REVIEW
Use command-cycle-matrix.json and original function-registry.json. For every
existing relevant command run apply/change/return/repeat and meaningful pair,
save/reopen/export as applicable. For navigation/cancel/report actions test actual
meaning; do not invent a reverseoperation. Record disabled/unavailable with cause.
Browserproof, componentproof, PDFstructure and actualrender proof remain distinct.

REPORT EACH OBSERVATION
build_id+manifestSHA; tool/reviewer/documentID; browser+viewport+DPR; exactbuttons
and keyboard sequence; expected/actual; before/after DOM+selection+styles; saved
state; screenshot; finalPDFfilename/hash/pages/text/linktarget; PASS/FAIL/NV;
knownissueID ifapplicable. Send observed problem to Codex. Codex traces code first,
provides9blocks then separate ownercandidate, repeatsoriginal/regression gates.
Internal code review is not Claude visual review. No Claude review has run yet.

PASS124 FINAL ADDENDUM
LIST-143 is a supplemental mandatory FAIL linked G02-C04/G08-C09/G13-C01.
70criteria remain12FAIL58NV;143defect rows,0of14sections closed.
Second reopened native119 document still15LI/12empty. Undo/Redo/History disabled.
Prepared starter repeat-ID field corrected;4 isolated API checks only, nativeNV.
Prepared core finalSHA c6c1f959d6fd1b93145dce5da3dbb0e26ceb710e0a6c87cda4cd979ab2fa1706.
No candidate browser acceptance and no Claude review yet.

ONLINE PASS125 ADDENDUM
Online origin https://pdf-qa.brodlin.com; links on root review portal. Historical localhost links above are inactive.
Claude reviewer=claude; Codex reviewer=codex, exact joint125 IDs. Same hosted origin; independent docs, no concurrent reviewer tests until pointer/storage behavior verified.
All37 product overrides unchanged. Native candidate acceptance pending. No PHP/DB/cloud writes.

FINAL ONLINE ADDENDUM
Editor: https://pdf-qa.brodlin.com/fill.html?reviewer=claude
Create: https://pdf-qa.brodlin.com/create-final.html?reviewer=claude
Manifest: /final-manifest.json;39effective Create owners; Fill retains37base owners. Do not edit Codex named documents. Same browser origin uses separate document IDs but shared legacy pointers; independent contexts are NOT VERIFIED. Server PHP/DB/cloud disabled; guest browser persistence only. This addendum is prepared, not proof of Claude execution.
Known limitations: PDF26 recovery/history/reset and failures open; disabled Undo/Redo/History in Foundation; partial/atomic list selection unchanged; non-disc/nested/checklist selectable export still open; selectable Hebrew broad acceptance open; mandatory formats/backend/mobile not accepted. Original export events captured exact PDF bytes; normal browser download delivery NOT VERIFIED.